Amish Approach to Discipline in Pennsylvania—What’s Really Happening Behind the Barn?

Could a Pennsylvania community known for simplicity hold secrets to discipline that challenge everything we assume? 🌐 #News #LancasterPA #Pennsylvania #Lifestyle

LANCASTER, PA — The Amish folks here in Pennsylvania are often pictured as a serene, old-world people—horse-drawn buggies clattering down rural lanes, plain clothes swaying in the breeze, and a lifestyle untouched by modern chaos. But beneath this tranquil surface lies a complex system of discipline that shapes their society. It’s not just about keeping the peace; it’s about preserving a way of life. So, what’s really happening behind the barn? Let’s peel back the curtain on how the Amish enforce rules, maintain order, and deal with those who stray.

The Foundation: Discipline Rooted in Faith

At the heart of Amish discipline is their unwavering faith. The Ordnung—a set of unwritten rules passed down through generations—governs everything from dress to technology use. It’s not a suggestion; it’s a sacred blueprint. Breaking these rules isn’t just a personal misstep—it’s a spiritual fracture that threatens the community’s covenant with God. Discipline, then, isn’t optional. It’s a holy necessity.

Parents start young, teaching obedience as a virtue tied to salvation. Proverbs 13:24, “He who spares the rod hates his son,” isn’t just a verse—it’s a playbook. Physical punishment, like spanking, is common for children, though it’s framed as an act of love, not anger. The goal? To guide, not to harm. But this isn’t a free-for-all—elders keep a close eye to ensure it stays within bounds.

Behind the Barn: The Reality of Correction

The phrase “behind the barn” conjures images of secret whippings, but the truth is less dramatic—and more communal. For kids, discipline might mean a switch or a stern talking-to, often in private spaces like a barn or woodshed. It’s quick, direct, and meant to leave a lesson, not a grudge. Adults, however, face a different beast: social and spiritual consequences.

Take shunning, or Meidung. If someone—say, a young man caught with a smartphone—defies the Ordnung after baptism, the community doesn’t rush to paddles. Instead, they turn to exclusion. No shared meals, no handshakes, no casual chats. It’s a slow burn, designed to pull the wayward back into the fold through isolation. Behind the barn isn’t always about a physical act; it’s about the weight of collective judgment.

Rumspringa: Discipline’s Wild Card

Then there’s Rumspringa, the Amish “running around” period. Teens get a taste of the outside world—think jeans, parties, even cars—before deciding to join the church. It’s a paradox: a sanctioned rebellion. But here’s the catch: it’s not a free pass. Families and bishops watch closely. Step too far—like getting arrested or pregnant—and discipline snaps back hard. Some face ultimatums: commit or leave. It’s a high-stakes test of loyalty, masked as freedom.

The Myths vs. The Facts

Outsiders often paint Amish discipline as harsh or archaic, whispering tales of beatings and tyranny. Reality is more nuanced. Yes, corporal punishment exists, but it’s not the norm for adults, and it’s rarely severe. A 2018 study from the Journal of Amish and Plain Anabaptist Studies found most Amish parents use spanking sparingly, favoring verbal correction or extra chores. Shunning, while emotionally brutal, stops short of violence. The barn isn’t a torture chamber—it’s a symbol of privacy in a tight-knit world.

Critics argue it’s oppressive, especially for women or doubters. Defenders say it’s consensual—everyone knows the rules before signing up. Either way, it works: Amish retention rates hover around 85%, far above most religious groups.

What We Can Learn: Discipline with Purpose

The Amish approach isn’t flawless. It’s rigid, sometimes unforgiving, and clashes with modern ideas of individual rights. But it’s deliberate. Every swat, every shun, every rule serves a bigger goal: community survival. In a world where discipline often feels aimless—think timeout tantrums or endless debates—the Amish offer a stark contrast. They don’t just punish; they correct with intent.

Behind the barn, there’s no mystery, just a system honed over centuries. It’s not about cruelty—it’s about clarity. Maybe we don’t need to borrow their switches, but we could steal a page from their playbook: discipline that means something, rooted in something bigger than ourselves.

Beyond the Stereotypes

The Amish aren’t saints or monsters—they’re people balancing tradition and human nature. Their discipline, from barn-side lessons to church-led shunnings, isn’t hidden in shadows; it’s woven into their daily lives. Next time you hear a buggy roll by, don’t just see the past. See a community that’s figured out how to hold itself together—one firm, faithful step at a time.

Do you have an uplifting story or fascinating news tip? Email us! news@jackandkitty.com.

RELATED TOPICS: Amish | Lifestyle | Pennsylvania

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Your opinion matters! Leave a comment below and join the discussion. We love hearing from you!

SHARE This Article With Family And Friends…