Delphi Murders Trial in Indiana: Will Libby German and Abby Williams Finally Get Justice?
After nearly 8 years of heartache and unanswered questions, Delphi’s community hopes the trial of Richard Allen will bring justice for Libby and Abby at last. 🌐 #News #CarrollCountyIN #Indiana #Crime
CARROLL COUNTY, IN – Nearly eight years ago, the quiet town of Delphi, Indiana, was shaken to its core when two teenage girls, Liberty “Libby” German and Abigail “Abby” Williams, went for a hike but never came back. Now, the man accused of their murders, Richard Allen, is standing trial—offering a chance for long-awaited answers in a case filled with heartbreak, mystery, and strange twists.
The Delphi Murders: A Chilling Day in February 2017
On February 13, 2017, best friends Libby German and Abby Williams set out for a hike near the Monon High Bridge, a former railroad bridge over Deer Creek. Libby’s older sister, Kelsi German, dropped them off around 1 p.m. for what seemed like an ordinary afternoon outdoors.
They never made it to the arranged pickup with their families later that day. After searching the area and finding no trace of the girls, their families reported them missing around 5:30 p.m.
The search continued late into the night and resumed early the next morning. Tragically, on February 14, the bodies of both girls were found along Deer Creek, about half a mile from the bridge where they had last been seen.
Clues Hidden in a Phone: A Haunting Video Leads the Investigation
Libby German’s quick thinking may have provided crucial evidence. On her phone, police discovered photos of Abby walking across the Monon High Bridge at 2:07 p.m. on February 13, as well as an image of an unknown man trailing the girls along the tracks.
Even more chilling, Libby managed to record audio of the man’s voice, capturing him saying the words, “Down the hill.” This audio and the suspect’s photo were soon released to the public. The recordings, coupled with two evolving composite sketches, became central to the investigation.
The first sketch, released in 2017, depicted an older man with stubble and shaggy hair, wearing a hooded jacket and a paperboy hat. However, police took a new approach in 2019, revealing a second sketch—this time showing a younger, clean-shaven man with curly hair.
Years of Frustration: False Leads and the Long Search for a Suspect
Despite tips pouring in and the case attracting national attention, investigators kept many details under wraps, leaving the public to wonder if the killer would ever be found. The investigation spanned years, with police following multiple leads, interviewing suspects, and urging anyone with information to come forward.
Finally, on October 26, 2022, the investigation took a decisive turn. Richard Allen, a licensed pharmacy technician at a local CVS and a long-time resident of Delphi, was arrested. Police linked him to the crime through a .40-caliber bullet casing found near the crime scene, which matched a firearm he owned.
Who Were Libby German and Abby Williams?
Libby German, 14, was a talented student involved in various activities, including volleyball, swimming, and band. She loved spending time with family and crafting, and she was known for her bright spirit and kindness.
Her friend Abby Williams, 13, shared Libby’s love for adventure and creativity. Abby enjoyed photography, reading, and decorating her mom’s house. Both girls were avid softball players, and in their honor, the community named a local park after them. Abby had a deep love for animals, especially her cat, Bongo.
The Accused: Richard Allen’s Trial Begins Amid Controversy
Richard Allen, now 52, had lived in Delphi since at least 2006. Married with an adult daughter, he worked at CVS, just a short five-minute drive from the Monon High Bridge. His arrest shocked the small town. How could someone from their own community be accused of such a heinous crime?
Allen was initially charged with two counts of murder and kidnapping in connection with the girls’ deaths. However, prosecutors later dropped the kidnapping charges, focusing instead on two counts of felony murder.
In a bizarre twist, Allen’s defense team claimed the girls were killed as part of a ritualistic sacrifice by a white nationalist cult. But a judge quickly barred any mention of this theory from the courtroom, leaving it out of the official trial proceedings.
Jury Selection Underway: Will Delphi Finally Get Answers?
Allen’s trial, originally slated for January 2024, faced multiple delays and rescheduling before finally moving forward in October. Due to concerns about the impartiality of local jurors, jury selection began on October 14, 2024, with jurors being bussed in from Allen County to Carroll County. The trial is expected to run until November 15.
Residents of Delphi remain hopeful but cautious. The trial’s progression is a step toward justice, but it also reopens wounds that never fully healed. The images and audio recordings from Libby’s phone, combined with the town’s deep-rooted grief, have kept the public invested in the outcome of this case for nearly eight years.
A Community on Edge: Searching for Justice and Closure
For Delphi’s 3,000 residents, the trial brings a complicated mix of emotions—hope, fear, and sadness. As the proceedings unfold, families of the victims and the community at large are holding on to the hope that the truth will finally come out.
The trial marks a new chapter in a case that has captivated the nation, but no matter the outcome, the memory of Libby German and Abby Williams will continue to live on. Their loss united a town and inspired a community to stand together in pursuit of justice.
A Town Clings to the Promise of Justice
The trial of Richard Allen offers a chance for long-overdue answers and closure.
As the trial unfolds, the families of Libby and Abby, along with the entire Delphi community, cling to the promise of justice. Though the pain of their loss will never fully fade, we pray that God’s grace will provide comfort and healing. In the face of tragedy, may they find peace in the belief that Libby and Abby are now in the loving arms of their Savior, free from the sorrow of this world.
Sign Up for Our Newsletter
We value your feedback! Did you find this article informative, inspiring, or thought-provoking? Leave a comment below and join the discussion. We appreciate your opinion and look forward to hearing from you!