Patriotic plate with burgers and hot dogs on grill. Curious about America’s top pick for July 4th BBQs? We've uncovered the ultimate crowd-pleaser that will leave you stunned!

Hot Dogs vs. Hamburgers: Find Out What Your Guests Actually Want On July 4th!

Curious about America’s top pick for July 4th BBQs? We’ve uncovered the ultimate crowd-pleaser that will leave you stunned! 🎇 #Food #News #4thOfJuly

The Ultimate 4th of July Showdown

EDINA, MN – With Independence Day on the horizon, it’s time to plan your festivities filled with fireworks, fun, and of course, food. For many Minnesotans, the big question for many is: Are you grilling hot dogs or hamburgers?

The Great American Food Debate

The debate between hot dogs and hamburgers is as old as time, rivaling even the ketchup versus mustard argument. But we’re here to settle one of these disputes: which is more popular on the 4th of July?

Instacart has provided some clarity on this topic by analyzing bun sales from the week leading up to last year’s 4th of July. Buns are a reliable indicator of which meat will be devoured since you’re unlikely to serve a hot dog on a hamburger bun.

Hamburger and hot dog on the Fourth of July

The Winner Takes All

After careful analysis, there was a clear victor in this culinary contest. The winner, which might surprise some, is… Hot dogs!

RELATED: Fascinating Facts About The Fourth Of July That Will Make You Proud To Be An American

Regional Preferences: A Culinary Map

Hot dogs and hamburgers have long been staples of July 4th barbecues. By examining bun sales, we get a glimpse into regional preferences for these classic cookout items. Data from the seven days leading up to July 4th, 2023, showed some interesting trends.

Hot dogs vs. hamburgers Inforgraphic by InstaCart
Courtesy: Instacart

The Southeast, Northwest, and Northern New England states showed a preference for burgers. However, hot dogs reigned supreme in 32 states, including Washington, D.C., making them the national favorite.

RELATED: The BEST Fourth Of July Jokes: Light Up Your Independence Day With Laughter!

Ranch dressing with veggies on a table

Condiment Preferences Across the Nation

Condiments play a crucial role in regional culinary preferences. Here’s what we discovered:

Mustard

In South Carolina, mustard-based barbecue sauces are a hit, and the tangy condiment is also favored in New Mexico and Colorado.

RELATED: Fascinating Facts About Fireworks: Mind-Blowing Trivia That Will Light Up Your World!

Hot Sauce

The West loves a spicy kick, with hot sauce being a popular choice to add some heat to their dishes.

Ranch Dressing

In America’s central heartland, ranch dressing is a staple, perfect for dipping and dressing a variety of foods. This should come as no surprise to us Midwesterners!

Fave condiments infographic by InstaCart
Courtesy: Instacart

Mayonnaise

The Northeast and Northwest favor mayonnaise, making it a go-to for fry dipping and burger topping.

RELATED: Do You Bleed Red, White, And Blue? Study Claims: These Are The Most Patriotic States!

Barbecue Sauce

Barbecue sauce is king in the South and Mid-Atlantic regions, an area often dubbed the “Barbecue Belt.”

Bringing you the BEST of the Midwest - travel guidebooks by Jack and Kitty

Celebrating with Flavor

As you prepare to fire up your grills and celebrate Independence Day, these insights into America’s food preferences might help you decide whether to serve hot dogs or hamburgers. Regardless of your choice, enjoy the flavors that bring us together in celebration. Happy 4th of July!

RELATED: Relish In Laughter: The Best Hot Dog Jokes To Mustard Up Some Giggles

Read the full report here.

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

SHARE This Article With Family And Friends…

Leave a Friendly Comment or Thought