Crime scene. A small Kentucky town is in shock after their trusted sheriff was charged with brutally murdering a judge inside the courthouse.

Kentucky Town Reeling After Shocking Courthouse Murder: Sheriff Accused of Killing Judge

A small Kentucky town is in shock after their trusted sheriff was charged with brutally murdering a judge inside the courthouse. 🌐 #News #WhitesburgKY #Kentucky #Crime

LETCHER COUNTY, KY – A small Kentucky town has been plunged into fear and disbelief after an unimaginable act of violence. Inside the very courthouse meant to uphold justice, a trusted local judge was brutally shot to death – by the sheriff himself.

A Violent End in the Courthouse: No One Is Safe

In a chilling scene straight out of a nightmare, District Judge Kevin Mullins was shot multiple times in his chambers by the man sworn to uphold the law — Letcher County Sheriff Shawn M. Stines. What was supposed to be a routine day in the quiet Whitesburg courthouse turned into a scene of horror as shots rang out, ending the life of a man who had dedicated 15 years to serving his community.

Sheriff Stines, a figure meant to protect, surrendered after the gruesome killing, leaving the town to wonder: If this can happen between the very pillars of justice, who is really safe?

A Town’s Trust Shattered

Whitesburg, a tight-knit Appalachian community where everyone knows each other, is now gripped by fear. This wasn’t just a headline—this was personal.

“We all know each other here,” said Matt Butler, the lead county prosecutor, who was forced to recuse himself due to his family ties with the victim. The murder struck so close to home that even those tasked with handling justice were too involved to continue.

No Escape from Violence

The disturbing reality is clear: the violence that seems to plague the outside world has now come to the heart of a peaceful, rural Kentucky town. The community has always been seen as a safe, quiet place to raise families. But now, many are rethinking that notion.

Kentucky’s Attorney General, Russell Coleman, vowed to investigate, but his promise of justice is little comfort to residents who now fear that the very people meant to protect them might turn into the next killer.

Kentucky Supreme Court Chief Justice Laurance B. VanMeter said he was “shaken” by the shooting. It’s a sentiment echoed in homes across the county as residents lock their doors, wondering what will happen next.

A Judge Who Fought for Others, Taken by Violence

Judge Mullins wasn’t just any judge. He spent his career helping those struggling with addiction and working tirelessly to bring healing to his community. He helped hundreds of people find treatment instead of jail. His efforts were a beacon of hope in the face of the opioid crisis, but now, that light has been extinguished in the cruelest way imaginable.

Even in a courthouse—supposedly the safest place in town—violence found its way in. Mullins had always been there to help others escape the traps of addiction and crime, but he couldn’t escape the violence waiting for him inside his own chambers.

Jack and Kitty Norton from JackAndKitty.com on YouTube

A Deepening Fear: What Happens Now?

Sheriff Stines has been charged with first-degree murder, but there are more questions than answers. Was this a momentary lapse or something more sinister? Why did the sheriff—who was trusted with the safety of the town—become the threat?

Kentucky State Police are continuing their investigation, but for the residents of Whitesburg, the sense of security has been shattered. The courthouse, once a symbol of justice, now feels like a crime scene that will haunt the town forever.

Unanswered Questions and Lingering Fear

In the aftermath of the killing, several area schools were briefly locked down. Parents rushed to get their children, terrified that the violence might spread. The courthouse has been closed until further notice.

This horrific murder has left the town on edge, wondering who they can trust and what might happen next. In the wake of such an unspeakable crime, the people of Whitesburg are left to pick up the pieces, but the sense of fear lingers in every corner of the town. No one ever expected to be scared of the very people who were supposed to protect them.

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

SHARE This Article With Family And Friends…

Leave a Friendly Comment or Thought