Murder, Mystery, and Messages from Beyond: How This West Virginia GHOST Shook a Nation!

A mother’s eerie bedtime visitation turned a quiet Appalachian death into a full-blown murder trial—and made history in the process. 🌐 #News #LewisburgWV #WestVirginia #WeirdNews

LEWISBURG, WV — When Elva Zona Heaster Shue was found lifeless in her Greenbrier County home in 1897, West Virginia officials first chalked it up to childbirth. But what came next pushed the boundaries of courtroom evidence, local superstition, and the limits of belief itself.

Little Feet, Big Mission

Zona, as she was known, had only recently wed Erasmus Stribbling Trout Shue, a local blacksmith with a mysterious past. The two had met in October 1896 and married shortly afterward. The couple’s short marriage came to a sudden end when Zona was discovered dead on January 23. Without a thorough examination, a physician quickly ruled her death as natural and linked to pregnancy complications. She was buried the next day in what is now known as the Soule Chapel Methodist Cemetery.

But Zona’s mother, Mary Jane Heaster, wasn’t convinced. She claimed her daughter’s spirit appeared to her multiple times after burial—desperate to reveal that Erasmus had murdered her.

Grave Doubts and a Grim Discovery

Fueled by these ghostly encounters and growing local whispers, Mary Jane went straight to the county prosecutor. His name was John Alfred Preston, and she spent hours in his office. Whether he believed her or simply saw enough community concern to act, he reopened the case.

Deputies began reinvestigating, and the attending doctor admitted he had not conducted a complete autopsy. That was enough to warrant exhumation. On February 22, Zona’s body was examined in a one-room schoolhouse. The results were chilling: her neck had been violently broken, her windpipe crushed, and finger marks showed clear signs of strangulation. The autopsy report was published on March 9, 1897. Her husband was immediately arrested for murder.

Cracks in the Past

As Shue waited for trial, his dark history began to unfold. He had been married twice before—one wife had accused him of cruelty, and another died under suspicious circumstances. Zona was his third wife. While jailed, Shue reportedly bragged about plans to eventually marry seven women and expressed confidence that he would walk free due to lack of evidence.

His confidence was misplaced. The trial began on June 22, 1897, and Mary Jane took the stand. Although the prosecution avoided mentioning the ghost, the defense, in a risky move, pressed her on the supernatural story. Unshaken, she repeated her claims with conviction, and the judge allowed the jury to consider her testimony.

Justice Served Without the Supernatural

Despite public fascination with the ghost story, the court convicted Shue on earthly evidence alone. On July 11, he was sentenced to life in prison. An angry lynch mob nearly pulled him from jail, but the sheriff intervened in time. Four of the mob’s organizers were later charged.

Three years later, Shue died behind bars during an outbreak of illness on March 13, 1900. He was buried in an unmarked grave—his past erased, but his crime never forgotten.

A Haunting Legacy

Decades later, the state of West Virginia erected a historical marker near Zona’s resting place. It reads:

“Interred in nearby cemetery is Zona Heaster Shue. Her death in 1897 was presumed natural until her spirit appeared to her mother to describe how she was killed by her husband Edward. Autopsy on the exhumed body verified the apparition’s account. Edward, found guilty of murder, was sentenced to the state prison. Only known case in which testimony from a ghost helped convict a murderer.”

It’s the only known instance in U.S. legal history where a ghost’s alleged testimony played a role in pushing a murder case forward, though the conviction ultimately relied on physical proof.

Zona’s story has lived on through books, stage plays, musicals, and even television. From Broadway-style productions to Drunk History episodes, her tale has captured imaginations far beyond the Appalachian hills. The most recent adaptation was a full opera, Everlasting Faint, which premiered in 2023 in Madison, Wisconsin. And in 2018, a behavior analyst even listed Zona as co-author of a research article in a professional journal—citing her as residing at “Soule Chapel Methodist Church, Smoot, WV.”

Did You Know?

• In the United States, fewer than 5% of murder cases are solved due to psychic or supernatural claims; most rely on forensic evidence and witness testimony (FBI Uniform Crime Reporting).
• West Virginia is home to dozens of ghost stories, but the Greenbrier Ghost remains its most legally significant paranormal case (WV Culture & History).
• The concept of using dreams or visions as evidence in court has roots in 17th-century England but is no longer legally admissible in the U.S. (National Criminal Justice Reference Service).

Moment for Reflection

Sometimes, love for a child pushes a parent to face ridicule, risk, and rejection. Mary Jane Heaster’s unwavering belief in her daughter’s voice—whether from memory or miracle—led her to uncover a brutal truth. Her courage is a timeless reminder that justice can rise from the most unlikely places, and that the bonds between mothers and daughters transcend even the veil between life and death. May we all listen a little more closely, even to the whispers the world might ignore.

Can you explain the Greenbrier Ghost? Have you ever had a paranormal encounter? Tell us in the comments!

As a thank you for reading this article, enjoy 25% off our new Feel Good Stories eBook. Do you have an uplifting story or fascinating news tip? Email us! news@jackandkitty.com.

RELATED TOPICS: Haunted Places | Paranormal | Weird News | West Virginia

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Your opinion matters! Leave a comment below and join the discussion. We love hearing from you!

SHARE This Article With Family And Friends…