Bear LAKE MONSTER Legend Grips Locals on Utah

An old-timey hoax has refused to die, fueling tourism, spawning quirky festivals, and keeping an eerie presence on the Utah–Idaho border. 🌐 #News #LoganUT #Utah #WeirdNews

LOGAN, UT — A lake straddling Utah and Idaho continues to stir imaginations and raise eyebrows over tales of a mysterious creature said to lurk in its depths. The Bear Lake Monster story exploded in 1868 when Joseph C. Rich, a settler and Latter-day Saint, published articles detailing supposed eyewitness reports of a monstrous lake-dweller. Despite eventually admitting the entire tale was fabricated, the legend took on a life of its own—and remarkably, sightings have persisted for more than a century.

A Beast of Many Faces

Descriptions of the creature remain wild and varied. According to folklore, the monster appears serpent-like, boasting stubby legs around 18 inches long and a cream-colored body that can stretch up to 50 feet. Witnesses have reported the monster moving faster than a train, slicing through water with a spine lined with spikes. Its head has been compared to animals as different as cows, otters, crocodiles, and walruses—minus the tusks. Some even claimed to see more than one.

An old-timey hoax has refused to die, fueling tourism, spawning quirky festivals, and keeping an eerie presence on the Utah–Idaho border.

Indigenous Lore and 19th-Century Frenzy

Long before Rich’s articles, Native American traditions reportedly spoke of a serpent-like being in Bear Lake, calling it a “water devil.” When Rich’s sensational reports hit newspapers, the legend gripped the region. In Salt Lake City, public curiosity spiked. Locals in the Bear Lake area nearly universally backed the claims, and the LDS Church took notice.

Leaders from the Church engaged with residents during missionary visits and collected reports they deemed credible. One prominent bishop described seeing a creature with fur-covered features, massive blue eyes, horse-like ears, and a fox-shaped face. The details were so vivid, believers insisted it couldn’t have been imagined.

Rival Papers and Monster Hunting Mania

While the Deseret News oscillated between support and skepticism, rival publications like the Salt Lake Tribune dismissed the entire affair with biting sarcasm. Even so, public enthusiasm remained high. One man proposed an elaborate capture plan involving buoys, ropes, and baited hooks. Church president Brigham Young sent a large rope to Paris, Idaho, reportedly hoping it could be used to reel in the lake’s elusive inhabitant.

The creature’s popularity crested before it faded into the background. Rich’s eventual confession—he had fabricated everything for attention—did little to deter diehard believers.

Sightings Never Stopped

Even after the hoax was revealed, the Bear Lake Monster refused to vanish from the local psyche. In 1907, two men claimed the creature attacked their camp and killed a horse. A child reported seeing it in 1937. A Boy Scout leader shared his encounter in 1946. The most recent report dates back to June 2002, when a Bear Lake business owner insisted he saw something strange swimming through the water.

From Folklore to Festival Fun

Today, the Bear Lake Monster is more than a creepy campfire story—it’s become a regional icon. A tourist cruise boat shaped like the creature once carried guests on a folklore-themed lake tour. Locals often lean into the legend with playful spirit. During Garden City’s Raspberry Days, children ride a float labeled “The Real Bear Lake Monsters.” In 1996, the town hosted a naming contest for the creature. An eight-year-old girl won with her pick: Isabella.

Did You Know?

According to the U.S. Geological Survey, Bear Lake is over 250,000 years old and spans more than 109 square miles (USGS).
In a 2023 National Geographic survey, 12% of Americans said they believe in lake monsters like the Loch Ness Monster or Bear Lake’s Isabella (National Geographic, 2023).
The tourism industry around Bear Lake brings in tens of millions annually, with events like Raspberry Days drawing tens of thousands of visitors each summer (Utah Office of Tourism).

Moment for Reflection

Even the wildest stories can bring people together. While the Bear Lake Monster might be more myth than menace, it has sparked laughter, tradition, and shared wonder across generations. In a world quick to dismiss mystery, maybe there’s room for a little whimsy—a reminder that faith, fun, and imagination can swim side by side. Whether fact or folklore, some tales ripple through time with a purpose greater than truth.

Have you ever seen the Bear Lake Monster? Had a paranormal encounter? Tell us in the comments!

As a thank you for reading this article, enjoy 25% off our new Feel Good Stories eBook. Do you have an uplifting story or fascinating news tip? Email us! news@jackandkitty.com.

RELATED TOPICS: Idaho | Paranormal | Utah | Weird News